Posting & Applying Online – Why it isn’t working!

With a recovering market there must be a lot of “great candidates” on the market – right? I believe that due to some unfortunate circumstances there are some “great” people out there looking. So when you post your jobs on Hcareers or any other job board why aren’t they applying?

I am fond of saying that the great thing about the internet is that it makes it easy to apply for any job you like and the bad thing about the internet is that it makes it easy for you to apply for any job you like.

What I mean is that the ease of the internet enables people to apply for jobs that they may not have considered before or even known about. People apply for jobs they feel qualified for, dream jobs they know that they are not qualified for but would love and really any job that catches their eye. They apply for jobs that are close to home, across the country or even in different countries. It all sounds incredibly exotic and exiting, but the reality is it produces little to no outcome 99% of the time.

Here’s why. Companies advertise job hoping to get a local candidate most of the time. The might look to a nearby region, locations within their own province or perhaps a neighboring province. Their last resort is someone on the other side of the country and the next option after last resort is an international candidate. The reality is that their comfort level is lower with a “long distance” candidate as they can’t see where you have worked or who you are, not to mention the cost to fly in “long distance” candidates for interviews and then relocate them can be thousands of dollars.

So when a job is advertised and 90% of the respondents are what would be considered unsuitable or “long distance”, hiring managers get frustrated. When a hiring manager posts several jobs and more that 90% of the dozens of resume they receive are not what they are looking for they get very frustrated. This frustration can lead to them not getting back to the people who may not be suitable regardless of where they live.

This failure to respond in return frustrates applicants. “Why apply online, they never get back to you” you might think. Many very qualified people have applied to several jobs online and not received any feedback at all which leads to their frustration in the online application system. I have heard from many very strong candidates that they choose not to apply online anymore as they do not get any results. So the breakdown of this system is in fact the reason some of the best people on the market may not be applying to your job ads.

So you have frustrated hiring managers and frustrated applicants with no effective way to connect! What to do.

I would love to hear your suggestions.

Views: 153

Comment by Kim Bechtel on February 25, 2010 at 10:34pm
Hey Corey, as usual, I find your insights to be truly noteworthy. There is so much 'the Emperor has no clothes' stuff going on in the HR world it is so refreshing to have you poking holes in some of these myths. High volumes of candidates has never meant high volumes of quality candidates, regardless of the application method! Keep it up big guy.
Comment by Sean Connell on February 26, 2010 at 3:55am
Like the thread, and having just come back from a Seminar by a job board company who quoted that they are proud to increase your applicaiton rate from 8 - 12, however based on 90% rule above that is just more cost for the outsourced response mgt company. What we should realy be focusing on is what you let individuals see, so many of the industry, myself included just drop the standard postings into fields which then loads via an agrigator of some nature, as it is far easier. I think we, as recruiters, should take some responisibilty and use greater advertising techniques to target our audience. I do agree with the ATS systems and a set of pre screening questions thereafter. Using Graphics, Audio, Video, Flash, Footprint tracking, advert positioning, and google add word search may reduce the dissappointment factor and hopfully limit the 90% unrequired.
Comment by Barbara Goldman on February 26, 2010 at 11:00am
I agree, nothing has changed. I have used newspaper, radio, television, and now the internet. 90% of the applicants aren't qualified. The other 10% then are filtered further. The difference is the volume of candidates. More unqualified people can see your ad.

Happy recruiting today everyone!

Comment

You need to be a member of RecruitingBlogs to add comments!

Join RecruitingBlogs

Subscribe

All the recruiting news you see here, delivered straight to your inbox.

Just enter your e-mail address below

Webinar

RecruitingBlogs on Twitter

© 2024   All Rights Reserved   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service