IS TECHNOLOGY THE MAGIC BULLET FOR RECRUITING

Technology is becoming an increasingly strong asset in all areas of business.  As companies become more complex, the need for technology grows and management is turning to technology for answers in all verticals.  Have we asked ourselves - is technology the answer at all?  Managers look to technology approaching issues with the question "What technology will solve this issue?"  They need to ask if technology is the answer at all, and then ask what technology might be the appropriate response.  This is never more obvious than in the recruiting and talent management verticals.  Each day more applications arise from various vendors promoting their software as the best management tool for finding, on boarding and then managing talent.  Some do it all, others do part of the process, but I believe the point is being missed all around.  Technology will never replace the human element of the recruitment and talent management sector.  No matter how many fields, how many applications, nothing replaces the human interface which is the core of recruiting employees.

 

Social networking, applicant tracking systems, etc are all executed by people.  These tools, though effective, are not stand alone.  They rely on the people that work within them and develop relationships based on the introductions they produce.  Communications will never be replaced with advanced systems.   People are people, phone calls and in person meetings are required for the most effective recruiters to acquire the best talent.  Recruiting is not a scientific algorithm, but an art in which skilled professionals effectively understand the human factor of recruiting - one in which matches more than simply hard skills but soft skills and company culture - characteristics that cannot be measured nor tracked by a computer. 

 

Recruiting is a knowledge based business, a true business intelligence solution.  This requires a professional with a diverse set of skills that can manage the systems that are used to assist with the massive amounts of data, but also the brilliant communications ability that can bring full circle the ability to not only locate people, but win them over to come and work for your company.  This skill cannot be measured by systems and can never be replaced by IT.  No automatic email will ever get someone to come work for your company.  In fact, it is more likely to turn someone off than actually assist the company.  Hiring decisions are not made on skill sets alone, actually it has been shown that most hiring decisions are made on non-essential elements (alumni, association, referrals, etc) when a capable candidate pool has been established.  How can all of these elements possibly be tracked?  They can't.  It requires a person to know another person, then and only then will the proper hire take place. 

 

Read more content like this at workfanatic

Views: 66

Comment by Martin H.Snyder on January 20, 2011 at 10:08am

"Recruiting" is a basic economic activity and is widely misused as a term of art because of the vast range of scale and process involved.   If you are hiring 3500 bank-tellers a year, that's a form of recruiting with very little in common with finding a few good plumbers to work for your small contracting firm.   Who wears the hat "recruiter'' varies from an older gentleman on fifth ave. with twenty names in his rolodex to a community college grad processing paper applications at a mom and pop retail store.  

 

The good (and interesting) thing is that because recruiting is SO basic, that pretty much all consumer and business technology evolution will in some way impact the process. 

 

Comment by Jason Monastra on January 27, 2011 at 1:59pm
Interesting perspective and I would agree there is wide range in the definition of recruiters.  However technology unfortunately is not the answer to everything.  I just sat a DOD conference focused on technology innovation for the improved process and effectiveness of certain defense IT programs.  The head of one of the largest programs made a great statement - IT is nothing without the people.  And that is what I am trying to get at.  IT is a tool, a bridge, a way for us to better manage time and resources.  However, place a kindergarden kid in front of it and the technology is only as effective as the user.  Companies need to stop focusing and looking for technology to solve the problem, they need to have the right people in the right places to leverage the technology.

Comment

You need to be a member of RecruitingBlogs to add comments!

Join RecruitingBlogs

Subscribe

All the recruiting news you see here, delivered straight to your inbox.

Just enter your e-mail address below

Webinar

RecruitingBlogs on Twitter

© 2024   All Rights Reserved   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service